home // Journal // Wall Street Journal

pdf downloadThe Tax Foundation - The Wall Street Journal's Misleading Income ...

The Tax Foundation - The Wall Street Journal's Misleading Income ... Source: delong.typepad.com
File Size: 255.45 KB
Page: 3 pages
Category: Journal

Share this info:


Short Description: May 16, 2011 ... The Tax Foundation - The Wall Street Journal's Misleading Income Chart. Page 1 of 3 http://www.taxfoundation.org/blog/show/27272.html ...

Content Inside: The Tax Foundation - The Wall Street Journal's Misleading Income Chart

5/16/11 5:29 PM

Site Search Go
Support the Tax Foundation Contact Subscribe

Home Research Areas Publications Tax Policy Blog Data, Charts, and Maps About Us Support the Tax Foundation Contact Us Press Room Tax Freedom Day Tax Policy Podcast Commentary Events Staff Center for Legal Reform Center for State Fiscal Policy
Tax Foundation National Press Building 529 14th Street, NW Suite 420 Washington, DC 20045-1000 202.464.6200
MAY 12, 2011

Printer Friendly

Send to a Friend

The Wall Street Journal's Misleading Income Chart
by Nick Kasprak The Wall Street Journal wrote an editorial last month making the point that there's no way to close our budget deficit by taxing only the rich. It's a point the Tax Foundation agrees strongly with, and the editorial's reasoning--that even if we confiscated 100% of the income of everyone in the top 1%, it still wouldn't be enough to close the deficit--makes sense. However, the editorial also includes a chart, which has been making the rounds on various blogs recently:

The Tax Policy Blog is the official weblog of the Tax Foundation, a non-partisan, non-profit research organization that has monitored tax policy at the federal, state and local levels since 1937. Our economists welcome your feedback. If you would like to send an email to the author of a blog post, please click on that person's name to locate his or her e-mail address or visit our staff page here.

Monthly Archives
May 2011 Go

Topics
Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) Bush-Era Tax Cuts: NearExpiration and Extension Capital Gains & Dividends Taxes Cigarette Taxes Compliance Costs & Tax Complexity Corporate Income Taxes Election Analysis

Regardless of the broader merits of the editorial, this chart is a textbook example of how to lie with statistics. It's unfortunate that the Wall Street Journal chose to undermine the rest of its editorial by including such a breathtakingly misleading image. It purports to show visually that the majority of taxable income in this country is made by those in the middle class--after all, the highest bar is for people making $100-$200K, which is in the middle of the graph! However, the heights of the bars depend as much on the width of your "bins" as on the actual statistic the bars measure. Look more closely: the bar immediately previous to this one is for the income range of $75K to $100K--an income range only one-quarter the size. Of course you're going to get a higher bar when you quadruple the income range it measures. The point here is that you can finagle the ranges for the bars any way you want, and get vastly different charts. To demonstrate this, I've created two very similar charts using the 2006 IRS Public Use File (the most recent data available.) It's easy to reproduce a very similar chart using the same binning as the Wall Street Journal's:

Environment and Energy Taxes , ( click to show subtopics ) Estate and Gift Taxes Excise Taxes, ( click to show subtopics ) Federal Taxes Paid vs. Spending Received by State Gross Receipts Taxes Income Taxes, ( click to show subtopics ) International Taxes Jock Taxes

http://www.taxfoundation.org/blog/show/27272.html

Page 1 of 3

Advertiser

download pdf for free Go to Download Page

Related PDF Files